Difference between Time Sharing OS and Multiprogramming OS

Last Updated : 03 Sep, 2024

An Operating System (OS) is a collection of software that manages computer hardware resources and provides common services for computer programs. The operating system is the most important type of system software in a computer system.

What is Time Sharing?

Time Sharing is the logical extension of multiprogramming, in this time-sharing Operating system, many users/processes are allocated with computer resources in respective time slots. In this, the processor’s time is shared with multiple users that’s why it is called a time-sharing operating system. It has a fixed time slice for the different processes. Its main purpose is interactive response time.

Example: Windows NT.

Benefits of Time-Sharing OS

Quick response.
Reduces CPU idle time.
All the tasks are given a specific time.
Less probability of duplication of software.
Improves response time.

Disadvantages of Time-Sharing OS

It consumes a lot of resources.
Requires high specification of hardware.
It has a problem of reliability.
Security and Integrity concerns.
Probability of data communication problem.

What is Multiprogramming?

Multiprogramming operating system allows to execute multiple processes by monitoring their process states and switching in between processes. In this processor and memory underutilization problem is resolved and multiple programs runs on CPU that’s why it is called multiprogramming. It has no fixed time slice for processes. Its main purpose is resource utilization.

Example: Mac OS.

Benefits of Multiprogramming OS

No CPU idle time.
Tasks runs in parallel.
Shorter response time.
Maximizes total job throughput of a computer.
Increases resource utilization.

Disadvantages of Multiprogramming OS

Sometimes long time jobs have to wait long time.
Tracking of all processes sometimes difficult.
Requires CPU scheduling.
Requires efficient memory management.
No user interaction with any program during execution.

Similarities

CPU Utilization Both aim to maximize CPU utilization by ensuring the CPU is always busy executing tasks.
Multi-tasking Both support the execution of multiple tasks or processes simultaneously.
Context Switching Both require context switching to manage multiple processes, ensuring each gets CPU time.
Memory Management Both rely on efficient memory management techniques to load and manage multiple processes in memory.
Process Scheduling Both utilize scheduling algorithms to determine which process or task should execute next.
Resource Sharing Both systems allow multiple processes to share system resources, like CPU, memory, and I/O devices.

Difference Between Time Sharing and Multiprogramming OS

Time Sharing	Multiprogramming
Time Sharing is the logical extension of multiprogramming, in this time sharing Operating system many users/processes are allocated with computer resources in respective time slots.	Multiprogramming operating system allows to execute multiple processes by monitoring their process states and switching in between processes.
Processors time is shared with multiple users that’s why it is called as time sharing operating system.	Processor and memory underutilization problem is resolved and multiple programs runs on CPU that’s why it is called multiprogramming.
In this process, two or more users can use a processor in their terminal.	In this, the process can be executed by a single processor.
Time sharing OS has fixed time slice.	Multi-programming OS has no fixed time slice.
In time sharing OS system, execution power is taken off before finishing of execution.	In multi-programming OS system before finishing a task the execution power is not taken off.
Here the system works for the same or less time on each processes.	Here the system does not take same time to work on different processes.
In time sharing OS system depends on time to switch between different processes.	In Multiprogramming OS, system depends on devices to switch between tasks such I/O interrupts etc.
System model of time sharing system is multiple programs and multiple users.	System model of multiprogramming system is multiple programs.
Time sharing system minimizes response time.	Multiprogramming system maximizes processor use.
Example: Windows NT.	Example: Mac OS.

Conclusion

Time Sharing and Multiprogramming operating systems (OS) both share many key characteristics, some of focus on maximizing CPU utilization, supporting multi-tasking, and best resource management. Both operating systems use techniques like context switching, process scheduling, and memory management. While Time Sharing is designed to provide quick response times for multiple users in better environment, Multiprogramming is more concerned with optimizing the throughput by running several programs concurrently.

Difference between Time Sharing OS and Real-Time OS

Satyabrata_Jena

Improve

Article Tags :